The four stages, and where the drill starts
| Stage | What it means |
|---|---|
| White spot | Enamel has lost minerals but has not broken. This is the reversible one. Fluoride, cleaning that exact spot properly and reducing how often you eat sugar can remineralise it. No filling needed, and we will tell you so rather than drilling it. |
| Enamel cavity | The surface has collapsed. It cannot heal, but it is a small, quick, comfortable filling and the nerve is nowhere near involved. |
| Dentine decay | Through enamel into the softer layer beneath, where it spreads faster and starts to feel sensitive to sweet and cold. Still a filling, but a bigger one. |
| Into the nerve | Now it is spontaneous pain, pain at night, or pain lingering after something cold. This is past filling territory and needs root canal treatment. |
The reason we take X-rays at a check-up is that decay between teeth is invisible to the eye and often painless for years. Catching it at stage one or two is the difference between a twenty-minute appointment and a root canal with a crown.
White composite or silver amalgam?
We place composite, the tooth-coloured material, for essentially all fillings. It matters for more than appearance: composite bonds to the tooth structure rather than being wedged into a shaped hole, so less healthy tooth has to be removed and the remaining walls are supported rather than stressed. Amalgam is durable and has served for over a century, but it requires cutting a mechanically retentive cavity, which means taking away sound tooth that did not need to go.
Should old amalgams be replaced?
Usually not, and we will tell you that even though replacing them would be the more profitable answer. A sound amalgam that is sealed, unbroken and has no decay under it is doing its job. Replacing it removes more tooth, and every re-restoration shortens the tooth's life a little. We do recommend replacing one when it is cracked, leaking, has decay underneath, or the tooth has fractured around it — all of which we can show you on the X-ray or the screen.
If you want amalgams changed for how they look, that is a perfectly reasonable request and we will do it, using high-volume suction and rubber-dam isolation during removal, after explaining that the trade-off is tooth structure. What we will not do is tell you that sound fillings are poisoning you in order to sell the work.
How a filling is done here
- Anaesthetic, unless the cavity is genuinely shallow. We would rather numb a small filling than have you tense through it.
- Rubber-dam isolation. Standard for every filling. Composite bonds chemically, and that bond fails if saliva reaches the tooth while it is being placed. This is the single biggest reason fillings leak early, and it is entirely preventable.
- Only the decay is removed, not a textbook shape. Modern adhesive dentistry is conservative by design.
- Layered and cured, shaped to your bite, then polished so the margin is smooth. A rough margin collects plaque and that is where the next cavity starts.
- Bite checked before you leave. A filling left slightly high causes days of soreness and takes two minutes to adjust.
Sensitivity afterwards: normal and not normal
Mild cold sensitivity for a few days, and tenderness on biting that improves, are normal, especially after a deep filling. What is not normal is pain that increases over the week, wakes you at night, or lingers for a minute or more after cold. That pattern means the nerve is inflamed rather than settling, and it is worth a call rather than a wait. Sometimes a high spot is all it is, which is a thirty-second fix.
When a filling is the wrong answer
There is a point where a tooth has lost too much structure for a filling to hold it together, and placing a bigger filling just delays a fracture. Signs we look for: the cavity involves most of the chewing surface, one or more cusps are undermined, there is an existing crack, or the tooth already has a large old restoration that keeps breaking. At that point a crown is the honest recommendation, and we will show you why on the photograph rather than asking you to take it on trust.
Not getting the next one
Decay needs bacteria, a fermentable sugar and time. You cannot remove the bacteria, so the levers are the other two. Frequency matters more than quantity: one dessert does less damage than six sweet coffees spread across a day, because each exposure restarts the acid attack. Brush twice daily with fluoride toothpaste and do not rinse with water afterwards, clean between the teeth once a day, and keep a hygiene visit every six months so the next one is found as a white spot rather than a root canal.